"I would start with a more diplomatic approach at first (with the train, not the raiders)... "hey, we can do this, we can help with that, we're useful..." or play on their emotions... "we have children and wounded people..." or try some kind of bartering system. Depends also on how valuable currency is at this point. I think raiding the train would be a last resort if the decision were mine. If I was outnumbered in the vote, I suppose I would join in on the raid. If you're desperate and facing certain danger you'll do just about anything to survive."

"D. Ask the train to stop and pick you up, even though its fully aware of raiders being in the area and how tricky they are.

Drop your guns and your jackets, let them know your not a threat. Get the women out where there they can see them. The children as well. Have faith in your fellow man and hope that they have mercy on you.

If they pass you by continue on any way you can with a concience clear of guilt. You'll find food water and shelter somewhere else. Maybe just not in that kind of abundance."

"You left out option F: Derail the train, salvage what you can, and then plant evidence that points to the raiders. Not saying I would do this, but it was one of the things to come to mind."

"Would it not seem rational that a stronghold with a rail system nearby would most likely trap or destroy the tracks in hope of a train stopping with supplies? I dont know how much I like the whole rail system, maybe it comes from playing to much Resident Evil 3, that train was way more hassle than what it was worth."